Infrastructure resilience in a digital age

Published: 4 Dec 2017

By: Juliet Mian

Tagged: ,

Juliet Mian

Infrastructure, like every other part of the economy, is experiencing the impact of the ‘fourth industrial revolution’ created by advances in data, digital systems and artificial intelligence.

Clients, government agencies, industry bodies and academics are beginning to understand and embrace how these technologies will change everything from the way we work together, to the way we operate and maintain the country’s infrastructure systems.

They offer unprecedented opportunities to transform infrastructure, increase capacity and make it more efficient and smarter.

This is truly exciting and opens up areas of massive potential. This could be through trialling autonomous vehicles across the UK, rolling out the Digital Railway to increase capacity over the next 25 years, or using data analytics from sensors to inform maintenance decisions.

Digital technologies can significantly increase the efficiency of our infrastructure systems. They can also make infrastructure systems more resilient, for example by providing information enabling rail passengers to re-route in real time if there is congestion. However, one downside is the potential for reduced resilience to unforeseen events.

To understand these less visible implications, the National Infrastructure Commission asked Arup and Dr Tom Dolan from University College London to investigate the impact of the increasing reliance on digital systems for infrastructure resilience. Our findings have been published today. This is a stand-alone piece of work that complements the Commission’s wider work on technology and infrastructure.

Our study involved research, a literature review, and cross-sector workshops. Cyber security is important, but stood outside our remit. Instead, we focused on accidents triggered by failures somewhere in a system and the extent to which these are inevitable. The end point that infrastructure system failures can lead to may be very similar, whether it’s triggered by cyber-crime, natural disasters or other system accident.

Infrastructure systems are already tightly coupled (small failures result in a chain of unstoppable events) and complex (behaviour can’t be predicted from the behaviour of individual components). Adding digital systems into the mix is likely to increase complexity, so we need to be aware of this, even if its unavoidable.

Our existing infrastructure has all sorts of vulnerabilities. While a digital overlay to infrastructure systems can improve aspects of performance and oversight, it won’t remove pre-existing physical vulnerabilities, and this interaction may indeed produce new properties which present their own risks.

These observations shouldn’t stop or reverse the implementation of new technology to improve resilience, but they should remind us to do so with careful consideration of the full implications of our decisions and not inadvertently create future problems.

UK infrastructure has traditionally operated largely in silos. However, an increased focus on resilience – whether digital or conventional – will I’m sure encourage greater cross-sector oversight to manage system interfaces and address interdependencies. I’d like to see resilience become a ‘golden thread’ that runs through all of government and industry’s infrastructure planning decisions.

Our report shows what we can start doing now to make that happen. Indeed, there’s a great opportunity here for the UK to provide global leadership in shaping the resilience of digital systems in infrastructure.

I look forward to seeing how the Commission and wider infrastructure community can collaborate to exploit the opportunities created through the application of new technologies, and to address the resilience challenges posed by these systems from the outset.

Dr Juliet Mian is an associate director in Arup’s Infrastructure Advisory team

Share this article


Recent Articles

Coming up in 2022
Thumbtack pins in calendar concept for busy, appointment and meeting reminder

Coming up in 2022

This page shows a calendar reflecting the latest expected dates for Commission reports, publications and events. You can also sign up to receive our quarterly newsletter by entering your email address in the box at the very foot of our homepage; or sign up to receive updates specifically on the programme for the second National...

22 Feb 2022 By
We’re recruiting – Senior policy adviser
Digital city image

We’re recruiting – Senior policy adviser

We have a great opportunity for an experienced policy professional with an interest in and good experience of the digital infrastructure space, but who also has the breadth of skills and knowledge that would allow them to work across all areas of our policy remit. Work is underway in earnest on our second National Infrastructure...

17 Aug 2022 By
We’re recruiting – Head of Governance
Image of a meeting pack

We’re recruiting – Head of Governance

The operational independence of the Commission is crucial both to the credibility of the advice it provides to government and its capacity to deliver its responsibilities effectively. To help achieve that, the Commission is supported by a number of boards and committees that oversee and monitor its performance and ensure that its duties are performed...

17 Aug 2022 By
Armitt on drought resilience: fixing leaks, reducing demand, building supply
Dry soil and patchy grass

Armitt on drought resilience: fixing leaks, reducing demand, building supply

In a comment piece for The Times’ Red Box, Commission Chair Sir John Armitt today sets out steps to help reduce the risk of future severe drought in England. The piece, reproduced below, argues for further action on identifying leaks, expanding water metering and reducing consumer demand, and building new supply and transfer infrastructure. Sir...

8 Aug 2022 By

Evidence_Icon_Turquoise Created with Sketch.

Explore data used in the Commission's research, and gain insights from across UK infrastructure

Join our team of professionals supporting the Commission to provide evidence based and forward thinking advice on infrastructure strategy.