Learning lessons from the first National Infrastructure Assessment

Published: 19 Mar 2019

By: Phil Graham

Phil Graham

Publishing the first National Infrastructure Assessment was a major milestone for the National Infrastructure Commission. It was significant for us as the first of the assessments that we are required to publish every five years reviewing long term infrastructure needs. It was also the first assessment of its kind in the UK.

This lack of precedent meant that we encountered many challenges while working on the Assessment which required new and creative solutions. As a new organisation, even many of the basics had to be developed largely from scratch. Needless to say, we learnt a lot along the way.

All too often with these kinds of projects, experience is quickly forgotten. Reviewing and responding to lessons happens informally; and any learning is kept within the organisation, rather than being open and consulting with stakeholders about what could have been done better.

But for the Commission’s work to be credible and influential, we need to show how we have learnt from the first Assessment, applying these lessons to our current work as well as future Assessments. That’s why we committed to undertake a formal ‘lessons learnt’ review to capture these reflections on the Assessment process. This is not a common exercise; a web search for ‘lessons learnt’ does not yield many similar reports, particularly for evaluating major projects rather than specific interventions.

Over the past few months we have carried out a comprehensive engagement process to gather feedback from our Commissioners, the members of our Secretariat and, most importantly, our external stakeholders. This included workshops, an online stakeholder survey and anonymised interviews.

Today we’ve published our findings, drawing out conclusions across eight themed lessons. These range from high level questions such as how we measure and communicate trade-offs between the Commission’s objectives, to more functional but vital tasks of managing our procurements and the programme of work effectively.

Some of these findings we have already begun to address or will do soon. Others we will return to when designing the process for the second National Infrastructure Assessment. All of these findings are useful and can improve our future work, but there are a couple of reflections from the lessons learnt review which I found particularly striking.

First, collecting feedback was an excellent reminder of the huge number of people who fed into the Assessment, including contributors from a wide range of sectors, places, roles and types of organisation, as well as members of the public. But we need to keep challenging ourselves to ensure that we are hearing as wide a range of perspectives as possible, particularly from groups that are typically under-represented in infrastructure decision making. I wrote a blog about this recently, highlighting the steps we have been taking to improve diversity internally and our aspiration to raise the profile of diversity across the infrastructure sector.

Second, the review was another reminder of the unique position of the Commission and the opportunity that provides. Although the Assessment couldn’t satisfy everyone given the breadth of opinions presented to us, the overall sentiment of feedback from stakeholders was very positive. This wasn’t just about the Assessment itself but also the Commission’s role in general, particularly the opportunity for thinking about infrastructure strategy over the long term and across sectors.

The challenge for us is to live up to that expectation in the way we work and the recommendations we make, and is something that we will reflect on as we develop our studies on Freight, Regulation and Resilience, and when we design the process for the next National Infrastructure Assessment. I hope that publishing this lessons learnt review today demonstrates that we genuinely want to listen and improve.

Share this article

<

Recent Articles

Coming up in 2022
Thumbtack pins in calendar concept for busy, appointment and meeting reminder

Coming up in 2022

This page shows a calendar reflecting the latest expected dates for Commission reports, publications and events. You can also sign up to receive our quarterly newsletter by entering your email address in the box at the very foot of our homepage; or sign up to receive updates specifically on the programme for the second National...

22 Feb 2022 By
We’re recruiting – Senior policy adviser
Digital city image

We’re recruiting – Senior policy adviser

We have a great opportunity for an experienced policy professional with an interest in and good experience of the digital infrastructure space, but who also has the breadth of skills and knowledge that would allow them to work across all areas of our policy remit. Work is underway in earnest on our second National Infrastructure...

17 Aug 2022 By
We’re recruiting – Head of Governance
Image of a meeting pack

We’re recruiting – Head of Governance

The operational independence of the Commission is crucial both to the credibility of the advice it provides to government and its capacity to deliver its responsibilities effectively. To help achieve that, the Commission is supported by a number of boards and committees that oversee and monitor its performance and ensure that its duties are performed...

17 Aug 2022 By
Armitt on drought resilience: fixing leaks, reducing demand, building supply
Dry soil and patchy grass

Armitt on drought resilience: fixing leaks, reducing demand, building supply

In a comment piece for The Times’ Red Box, Commission Chair Sir John Armitt today sets out steps to help reduce the risk of future severe drought in England. The piece, reproduced below, argues for further action on identifying leaks, expanding water metering and reducing consumer demand, and building new supply and transfer infrastructure. Sir...

8 Aug 2022 By

Evidence_Icon_Turquoise Created with Sketch.

Explore data used in the Commission's research, and gain insights from across UK infrastructure

Join our team of professionals supporting the Commission to provide evidence based and forward thinking advice on infrastructure strategy.