What makes good design? Commission's Principles help frame civil engineers' approach

The Commission's Design Group collaborated with the Institution of Civil Engineers on a major report on how design is approached in projects

Published: 13 Jul 2021

By: Ben Wilson

Tagged: ,

Cover of report on good design in infrastructure by the ICE and NIC

The National Infrastructure Commission’s Design Group has collaborated with the Institution of Civil Engineers on a major report examining the barriers to embedding good design at every stage of infrastructure projects.

In September 2020, the ICE, in collaboration with the Commission’s Design Group, surveyed ICE members to establish how relevant they believed the Commission’s four Design Principles to be to their work, and to discover more about how they perceived their own role in the development of good design.

What makes good design?, published on 13 July 2021, sets out the key findings – including that about 60% of respondents think climate issues are not given enough importance in design; and that while they believed that wherever they were in the project lifecycle they had a responsibility to influence design, respondents also believed the skills to achieve this were lacking.

While the survey responses were being analysed, government announced that it had adopted the Commission’s recommendations on design made in the National Infrastructure Assessment, highlighting the call for a design champion to be appointed on every major infrastructure project.

Based on the survey findings, and input from the Design Group, the ICE has identified recommendations to pursue both for itself and in collaboration with other bodies.

Judith Sykes, the report’s steering group lead, ICE Fellow and NIC Design Group member, said: “In the context of the industry’s net zero aspirations, it may surprise some that climate is regarded as the least addressed design principle within the survey.

“Good design remains critical if we are to use our limited resources to find creative approaches to meeting our carbon reduction targets, deliver on the levelling-up agenda and create healthy communities.

“With a greater understanding of how the principles are understood, this research enables us to improve our strategic decision-making processes and foster a design culture in infrastructure delivery. This requires collaborating with organisations, such as ICE, that are committed to elevating design practice.”

Read the report

Share this article

Recent Articles

Coming up in 2022
Thumbtack pins in calendar concept for busy, appointment and meeting reminder

Coming up in 2022

This page shows a calendar reflecting the latest expected dates for Commission reports, publications and events. You can also sign up to receive our quarterly newsletter by entering your email address in the box at the very foot of our homepage; or sign up to receive updates specifically on the programme for the second National...

22 Feb 2022 By
Commission hears from West Midlands on region’s infrastructure priorities

Commission hears from West Midlands on region’s infrastructure priorities

What West Midlands needs to build a thriving regional economy – and the role infrastructure can play in helping achieve that goal – was on the agenda for the Commission’s regional visit to Birmingham last week, the second in a series of six visits to cities and city regions around the country designed to help...

4 Jul 2022 By
Getting cities moving past “Covid fog” critical for success of levelling up 
A Birmingham tram reflected in a wet platform

Getting cities moving past “Covid fog” critical for success of levelling up 

Enabling people to make more trips in and around our major cities is a challenge that city leaders and national government must tackle head on by making urban transport networks work better – within carbon constraints – if they are to achieve levelling up, according to a new report from the National Infrastructure Commission. The...

30 Jun 2022 By
Government’s next steps on freight: welcome ambition, detailed plans now needed
Articulated lorry overtaking another lorry on a motorway

Government’s next steps on freight: welcome ambition, detailed plans now needed

This week the government published its long-term plan for the freight sector, Future of Freight. Government committed to publishing this in its response to the Commission’s 2019 study, Better Delivery: The challenge for freight. The Commission’s main conclusion in that study was that through the adoption of new technologies and the recognition of freight’s needs...

16 Jun 2022 By

Evidence_Icon_Turquoise Created with Sketch.

Explore data used in the Commission's research, and gain insights from across UK infrastructure

Join our team of professionals supporting the Commission to provide evidence based and forward thinking advice on infrastructure strategy.